By Mark Milke
and Lennie Kaplan
Canadian Energy Centre
Between 1969-2019, Canadian parents received $499 billion in family allowance payments and children’s benefits from the federal government.
That 50-year cost was matched by $505 billion in revenues to governments from the oil and gas sector – except that such taxpayer cash was collected over just 20 years, between 2000-19.
That included everything from oil and natural gas royalties to corporate and personal income taxes [from those in the oil and gas sector] to property taxes.
The roughly half-trillion dollars in taxes and royalties from oil and gas over the past two decades matched up with a similar amount paid out to families for child benefits over five decades is an inexact comparison.
Plenty of other taxes flow into government coffers. There are also multiple other items that Canada’s governments spend tax dollars on, from health care to highways and much else.
But the child benefit/oil and gas revenues comparison helps provide a concrete comparison to those who know little about taxes and government spending, or mistakenly think governments can spend with little regard for the strength of a major Canadian industry.
To illustrate the critical importance of oil and gas revenues to governments – and thus to Canadians – consider a comparison to other major Canadian industries.
Real estate and construction are also major contributors to government coffers. Between 2000-19, the real estate sector contributed just over $211 billion in taxes to governments across Canada, or about two-fifths of what oil and gas did. The construction sector handed over $298 billion to federal, provincial and local governments over the same two decades, or about three-fifths of what those involved in the natural gas and oil industries sent to Ottawa, the provincial capitals and local governments.
Add the real estate and construction sectors and their $509-plus-billion contribution barely tops the $505 billion Canadian governments received from oil and gas companies and employees between 2000-19 [the latest year for which data is available].
The $505 billion from oil and gas is just oil and gas taxes and royalties to local, provincial and federal governments. It doesn’t include payments to First Nations.
Also, we were unable to track personal income tax payments from oil and gas workers to provincial and federal governments between 2000-06. So even the half-trillion bonanza of revenue from the oil and gas sector is a conservative estimate.
Also, we’re sometimes asked what the comparison is between oil and gas revenues and, say, manufacturing revenues. Those comparisons are hard to come by [and calculate] because people mistakenly think manufacturing is, for example, all located in central Canada and attached to the aerospace and automotive sectors.
In fact, manufacturing happens in many industries, not just when a company creates an auto from steel or when an airplane manufacturer creates a jet. It includes when steel rigs are created to drill for oil and natural gas, or when pipes are fashioned to carry oil or gas to and from refineries and to trains and ships for transport. So we can’t compare the manufacturing sector to the oil and gas sector because the oil and gas sector includes manufacturing and we’d double-count revenues.
The broad energy sector includes oil and gas extraction and support activities, and utilities, coal and pipeline transportation. Total energy revenues between 2000-19 were $701 billion [including the $505 billion from oil and gas], or more than all the federal government spent on employment insurance between 1987-2019 [$685 billion].
If Canada’s oil and gas sector disappeared tomorrow and governments were forced to find $505 billion in tax revenues, they might start pondering hikes in personal, business, payroll or sales taxes, or some combination.
And they’d need to find $25 billion a year to replace oil and gas revenues.
- Mark Milke and Lennie Kaplan are with the Canadian Energy Centre, an Alberta government corporation funded in part by carbon taxes.